Share optimized solutions, professional valve knowledge and industry news

Please enter the relevant terms or keywords you need to consult, and relevant articles will appear in the search results. If you can’t find the answer you need, please feel free to contact us and we will be happy to help. Or you can directly send an email to [email protected]

What is Failure Position of Control Valves and How to Solve it?

The critical role of the control valve in the processing system is well known. The control valve's regular operation requires the system to provide air/electricity source and signal source.
Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

    The critical role of the control valve in the processing system is well known. The control valve’s regular operation requires the system to provide air/electricity source and signal source. The correct provision of the air/electricity source and the signal source is the control valve’s essential operation. Due to the control valve’s critical position, the process control system is required to ensure that the air/electric source and signal source can be correctly and continuously provided to the control valve. The actual situation is that the process control system cannot guarantee 100% correct and continuous provision of the above air/electricity source and signal source (three sources for short) without any deviation. Therefore, it must take corresponding protective measures on the control valve, namely, the three source failure(air failure, power failure, signal failure) position protection measures.

    There are many kinds of control methods of control valves, and accessories are various, so the three sources of failure protection measures and solutions of control valves will be different. General need to have position feedback devise for control valves if required three source failure protection measures. It means need a feedback signal to the control system, also assembly with handwheel/handle to achieve manual operation in case of failure.
    According to the different requirements of three sources of failure protection, this article lists other protection solutions and analyzes various schemes to discusses with industry counterparts.

    The three sources of protection schemes discussed in this article mainly include the following:

    a. Eletro-Pneumatic Digital Positioner Solution(It means the control valve assembly with E/P smart positioner)
    b. Eletreo-Pneumatic Analog Positioner Solution (It means the control valve assembly with E/P valve positioner)
    c. Eletro-Pneumatic Converter + Pneumatic-Pneumatic Valve Positioner Solution (It means the control valve assembly with an electro-pneumatic converter and P/P valve positioner)
    d. Analog Pneumatic Positioner Solution (It means the control valve assembly with P/P valve positioner)
    e. Intelligent Electric Control Valve Solution


    a. Eletro-Pneumatic Digital Positioner Solution

    Eletro Pneumatic Digital Positioner Solution
    Eletro Pneumatic Digital Positioner Solution

    This program is mainly composed of a pneumatic control valve, intelligent electric-pneumatic valve positioner, power loss (signal) comparator, single-coil solenoid valve, air-lock valve, and so on. Its working principle is as follows:

    1. Air source failure: When the air supply of the control system failure (means lost air), the air-lock valve automatically closes to lock the output signal pressure of the positioner in the diaphragm chamber of the pneumatic control valve, and the output signal pressure is balanced against the reaction force generated by the control valve spring, the valve position of the pneumatic control valve remains at the fault position. The air-lock valve should be set to start slightly below the minimum value of the air supply.
    2. Power source failure: When the power supply of the control system fails (power loss), Loss of power (signal) comparator control the output voltage disappeared, the single-coil solenoid valve loses power, and its spool valve inner of solenoid valve slides under the action of the return spring, the solenoid valve is reversed, the pressure of the diaphragm chamber of the pneumatic retaining valve is emptied, the pneumatic retaining valve is closed, and the output signal pressure of the positioner is locked in the pneumatic control valve In the diaphragm chamber, the output signal pressure is balanced with the reaction force generated by the diaphragm spring, and the valve position of the pneumatic control valve remains at the failure position.
    3. Signal failure: When the control system signal is faulty (signal loss), after the power loss (signal) comparator detects it, the voltage signal of the single-coil solenoid valve is cut off. The spool valve in the solenoid directional control valve slides under the action of the return spring. The solenoid valve reverses to empty the air-lock valve pressure and closes the air-lock valve to locks the output signal pressure of the positioner in the diaphragm chamber of the control valve. The output signal pressure is balanced with the reaction force generated by the control valve spring. The valve position of the pneumatic control valve remains at the failure position.

    The electric-pneumatic smart positioner gives the position feedback signal and no need for a valve position signal returner. General, the smart electric-pneumatic valve positioner itself can realize the position feedback with its own or additional position feedback module.

    This solution’s advantages: relatively few accessories are used (no valve position signal returner is needed), and it takes up less space. Installation and debugging are more convenient, simple, and fast. When the “three failure” protection is activated, the system reacts quickly and acts quickly.

    This solution’s weakness: the solenoid valve is charged for a long time, which affects the service life. The overall cost is relatively high, and the reliability of the accessories is relatively high.


    Eletreo Pneumatic Analog Positioner Solution
    Eletreo Pneumatic Analog Positioner Solution

    b. Eletreo-Pneumatic Analog Positioner Solution

    This solution is mainly composed of a pneumatic control valve, analog electric-pneumatic valve positioner, power loss (signal) comparator, single-coil solenoid valve, pneumatic retaining valve, valve position signal returner, etc. Its working principle is the same as the smart electric-pneumatic valve positioner scheme.
    The valve position signal returner gives the position feedback signal.
    The advantage of this solution: When the “three sources failure” protection starts, the system reacts quickly and acts quickly. The overall cost is lower than option a.
    The disadvantage of this solution: the solenoid valve is charged for a long time, affecting the service life. There are many accessories, and the installation and debugging are more complicated than the solution a. The valve position feedback needs to be equipped with a valve position signal returner. In the case of a handwheel, it is more complicated.


    c. Eletro-Pneumatic Converter + Pneumatic-Pneumatic Valve Positioner Solution

    Eletro Pneuamtic Convertor Pneumatic Pneumatic Valve Positioner Solution
    Eletro Pneuamtic Convertor Pneumatic Pneumatic Valve Positioner Solution

    This program is mainly composed of a pneumatic control valve, analog pneumatic valve positioner, electric-pneumatic converter, air-lock valve, valve position signal returner, etc. Its working principle is as follows:

    1. Air source failure: When the air source of the control system fails (lost air), the pneumatic retaining valve used to control the loss of the air source is automatically closed, and the output signal pressure of the positioner is locked in the diaphragm chamber of the pneumatic control valve to output the signal pressure In balance with the reaction force generated by the control valve spring, the valve position of the pneumatic control valve remains at the fault position. The retaining valve should be set to start slightly below the minimum value of the air supply.
    2. Signal failure: When the control system signal fails (signal loss), the output signal pressure of the electric-pneumatic converter is synchronously lost, and the air-lock valve used for the control signal loss is automatically closed to lock the output pressure of the diaphragm chamber of the actuator, the output signal pressure is balanced with the reaction force generated by the control valve spring, and the valve position of the pneumatic control valve remains at the failure position. The air-lock valve should be set to start when it is slightly lower than the input signal’s minimum value.
    • No power supply failure position of the control valve is needed.
    • The valve position signal returner gives the position feedback signal.

    The advantages of this solution:

    • No power supply failure position of the control valve is needed.
    • Only two failure valve position of a valve is required.
    • It can be used on occasions with strict requirements for explosion protection.

    Disadvantages of this solution: when the signal is a failure, there is a very short lag, and more accessories are used. The installation and debugging are more complicated than the solution (a). The valve position feedback needs to be equipped with a valve position signal returner. In the case of rounds, it is more complicated.


    d. Analog Pneumatic Positioner Solution

    Analog Pneumatic Positioner Solution
    Analog Pneumatic Positioner Solution

    This program is mainly composed of a pneumatic control valve, analog pneumatic valve positioner, air-lock valve, valve position signal returner, etc. Its working principle is as follows:

    1. Air source failure: When the air source of the control system fails (lost air), the air-lock valve used to control the loss of the air source is automatically closed, and the output signal pressure of the positioner is locked in the diaphragm chamber of the pneumatic control valve, the output signal pressure is balanced with the reaction force generated by the control valve spring, and the valve position of the pneumatic control valve remains at the fault position. The air-lock valve should be set to start slightly below the minimum value of the air supply.
    2. Signal failure: When the control system signal fails (signal loss), the pneumatic air-lock valve used to control the signal loss is automatically closed, and the output signal pressure of the positioner is locked in the diaphragm chamber of the pneumatic control valve, and the output signal pressure and control The reaction force generated by the valve spring is balanced, and the valve position of the pneumatic control valve remains at the fault position. The air-lock valve should be set to start when it is slightly lower than the input signal’s minimum value. When the signal is failure, there is a certain lag, and the lag time is related to the pneumatic signal pipeline’s length.

    The advantages of this solution:

    • No power supply failure position of the control valve is needed.
    • The valve position signal returner gives the position feedback signal

    The advantage of this solution: It is equipped with fewer accessories, which is convenient for installation and debugging. The overall cost is low, and it can be used in occasions with exceptionally high requirements for explosion protection.

    Disadvantages of this system: when the signal is failure, there is a certain lag related to the length of the signal pipeline. Valve position feedback requires an additional valve position signal returner, which is more complicated when equipped with a handwheel. Only suitable for pneumatic signal occasions.


    e. Intelligent Electric Control Valve Solution

    The intelligent electric control valve is composed of a smart electric actuator and a valve. The intelligent electric actuator itself has the function of power-off and position retention. When the signal is interrupted, it can select the functions of keeping the original position, fully closed and fully open. And it has a signal feedback function. So it has a wide application range.
    The advantage of this solution: No need to connect to the air source, only two failure protection can be realized, with less installation space. Installation and debugging are more convenient, simple and fast. When the “two breaks” protection is activated, the system reacts quickly and acts quickly. The valve itself has a signal feedback function, and there is no need to install a valve position signal returner.
    Disadvantages of this system: the overall cost is relatively high, and the use is limited in occasions where explosion-proof requirements are particularly strict.
    The above solution is the most basic scheme of the three-break protection scheme, and during the three-break, the valve remains in the original position (hold position).
    If you need other protection methods, you can change the above scheme.
    The following introduces a protection scheme in which the double-acting valve fully opens or fully closed when the air source fails (loss of air).

    Intelligent Electric Control Valve Solution
    Intelligent Electric Control Valve Solution

    This program is mainly composed of control valves, pneumatic reversing valves, positioners, self-locking valves, check valves/non-return valve, air regulator, gas storage tanks, etc. Its working principle is as follows:
    When the air source of the control system fails (lose air), the self-locking valve (the function of which is opposite to that of the retaining valve) will automatically open to cancel the air source of the air-controlled directional valve. The slide valve of the air-controlled directional valve is reset under the action of spring, one of the air-controlled reversing valves is exhausted, the other is aired, and the non-return valve is closed. The air source is supplied to the valve from the gas storage tank, to realize the valve fully closed or open. It can recognize a fully closed or fully open by adjusting the pneumatic control valve’s connection mode.
    If you want to realize valve retention, install a pneumatic retention valve, change the pipeline connection, use a self-locking valve to control the air-lock valve directly, and cancel the pneumatic control reversing valve, check valve and gas tank.
    If you want to ensure that the valve has several actions when the air source is failed, the following solutions can be used.

    Air Failure Ensure Valve Keep Actions. 1
    Air Failure Ensure Valve Keep Actions. 1

    This scheme consists of a gas storage tank, a check valve, a blocking valve, a globe valve, etc. Its working principle is as follows:
    When the air supply fails (loss of air), the check valve is closed, the lock valve loses air, the slide valve of the lock valve is reset under the action of the spring, the air circuit is reversed, the air source pipeline of the system is disconnected, and the gas storage tank supplies gas to the valve to ensure that the valve has several actions to achieve the purpose of continuous control. Due to the gas storage tank’s limited capacity, and the pressure of the air supply in the gas storage tank continues to decrease with the valve action, the gas storage tank cannot be used for a long time to supply air to the valve. The capacity of the gas storage tank for this plan should be larger than that of the general protection gas storage tank. In this system, when the air supply fails, the number of valve actions is related to the gas storage tank’s capacity.
    The several protection schemes listed above are just a few primary forms. To achieve different protection purposes, the above schemes can be appropriately modified. Since the documented system has its own advantages and disadvantages, a different method can be according to specific conditions of the site. For the three-break protection, when the budget is possible, combining various factors, the author recommends the plan (a) and plan (e).

    Facebook
    Twitter
    LinkedIn
    Pinterest
    Print
    Picture of Will Don

    Will Don

    After earning my bachelor's degree in mechanical engineering from Zhejiang Normal University in 2008, l was fortunate enough to begin my career with Siemens, Fisher, and YTC, focusing on control valve accessories. Over the past dozen years, l've poured my heart and energy into understanding technology and fluid solutions for control valves.
    Now, as the marketing director for THINKTANK, a trusted branch of the Taiwan STONE valve group, I can't help butf eel proud of how far we've come. Our knowledge isn't just reaching professionals like engineer and valve distributors; it's also inspiring the next generation of automation college students.
    l genuinely hope you're enjoying our articles and finding them helpful.Your thoughts, questions, and feedback mean the world to me, so please don't hesitate to reach out to marketing[at]cncontrolvalve.com. Whether you're a seasoned expert or just curious about the field, I'm here to connect, share, and learn together.

    All Posts »

    I am the author of this article, and also the CEO and marketing director of THINKTANK, with 15 years of experience in the industrial valve industry. If you have any questions, you can contact me at any time.

    Subscribe Now

    Receive the latest product information and industry news.

    We value your privacy. Your information will be kept confidential.

    Contact Us

    Just fill out your name, email address, and a brief description of your inquiry in this form. We will contact you within 24 hours.

    The Latest News
    axial piston high pressure pump

    High Pressure Pumps Axial Piston Pumps

    In the past 5 years, we made our HPR/HPH series axial piston pumps as OEM products for a well-known brand. These pumps have been successful ...
    Read More
    breaker valve manufacturer

    VB14 and VB21 Vacuum Breaker Installation

    VB14 Vacuum Breaker Description VB14 is a small special vacuum breakers used in condensing vapour/steam or liquid systems, and it made of Brass material, and ...
    Read More
    common valve abbreviation guide

    Common Valve Abbreviation Guide

    In industrial manufacturing and instrument maintenance, you’ll see many abbreviations for valves. It’s important for engineers, maintenance people, and students to know these abbreviations because ...
    Read More
    spray & fuse coating

    Comprehensive Technical Guide on Hard Coating For Severe Service Valve

    One of the most effective ways to improve the durability and performance of valves in in severe service environments, where valves are work at extreme ...
    Read More
    dosing valve DN100 lime dosing system

    What is a Lime Dosing Valve and How Does It Work

    In the world of water treatment and chemical processing, it’s important to control lime dosing accurately. Getting the pH right and avoiding lime blockages can ...
    Read More
    concentrated solar power schematic

    Selection and Application of Molten Salt Control Valves

    In recent years, as the environmental impact of traditional energy sources such as coal and petrochemicals has become more and more of a concern, there ...
    Read More
    molten salt power system

    Comprehensive Guide of Molten Salt Valve

    In the world of advanced energy systems, molten salt valves are a critical component for controlling high-temperature fluids that are important for storing and transferring ...
    Read More
    lined ball valves akh5

    Top 10 Ceramic Valves Manufacturers in 2024

    Ceramic valves are used in highly demanding services including slurry, erosive, corrosive, and scaling applications.
    Read More
    globe control valve body

    Información sobre los tipos de válvulas industriales

    Existen numerosos tipos de válvulas industriales, que pueden alcanzar hasta varios cientos, y cada tipo de válvula está diseñado para satisfacer las necesidades específicas ...
    Read More

    Contact Us

    With expertise in valves and rich experience in the oil&gas, chemical industry, textile mills, power plants, and sugar mills. THINKTANK has become the premier manufacturer of next-generation precision control valves.

    With a customer base that includes over 42 of the world’s leading engineering&contractors and international valve brands, THINKTANK Valves offers cost-effective valves that help our customers achieve automated process control without paying high prices.

    Why are more and more international valve brands choosing THINKTANK for OEM service?

    Brand is reputation, which not only requires high valve technology, but also great comercial support and fast response after-sales service and delivery time. They will not gamble their brand on an unknown product

    Get an Instant Quote

    Avoid your inquiry is delay response, please enter your WhatsApp/Wechat/Skype along with the message, so we can contact you at the very first time.

    We will reply you within 24 hours. If for urgent case, please add WhatsApp: +86 185 1656 9221, or WeChat: +86 199 2125 0077. Or call +86 189 5813 8289 directly. 

    Get An Instant Quote

    Joy Preview

    Get An Instant Quote

    We will reply you within 24 hours. If for urgent case, please add WhatsApp: +86 199 2125 0077, or WeChat: +86 199 2125 0077. Or call +86 189 5813 8289 directly. 

    Direct to Control Valve Factory With Competitive Price & Reliable Quality

    Joy Preview
    Joy Preview

    Get An Instant Quote

    Just leave your name, email, and simple message or requirements, We will contact you within 1 hour.

    WhatsApp: +86 199 2125 0077

    Skype ID: sowell85

    Wechat ID: +86 199 2125 0077